Skip to main content
Displaying 1 of 1
Nine women : short stories
1986
Availability
Trade Reviews
Library Journal Review
Grau's short stories are peopled by men and women who embrace habit and tradition. But while their rituals comfort, they also mask communication. The parents who live on a rigid schedule in ``Letting Go'' cannot talk to their daughter; the wedding ceremony in ``Ending'' also marks the end of the parents' marriage; and a yearly Labor Day clambake in ``Summer Shore'' is more a celebration of superficial ``summer friends'' than of the end of the season. Unfortunately, the style does not measure up to Grau's previous work: the quality of the dialogue is uneven, the prose marred by cliches and repetitive metaphors. From the author of the Pulitzer Prize-winning The Keepers of the House, these stories are disappointing. Lucinda Ann Peck, Learning Design Associates, Gahanna, Ohio (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publishers Weekly Review
Infrequent in appearance, Grau's books are always an occasion for celebration. The nine stories in this new collectionall with a woman as their central characterconfirm her as a writer of keen psychological insight and luminously resonating prose. Grau's sensibility has an amazing range: outside of the Southern heritage they share, her women inhabit different social, economic and cultural worlds. ``Hunter'' concerns the only survivor of a plane crash that kills her family, who thereafter pursues her own surcease. Marvelously restrained, with every word polished to a burning clarity, the story engulfs and mesmerizes the reader. In ``Ending,'' the wedding of the daughter of an affluent black couple signals the dissolution of their marriage and exposes the disillusion that has eroded their upwardly mobile lives. Perfect in pitch and tone, ``Home'' captures an emotional confrontation between two women who are lovers, but ends in a reaffirmation of their vital connection. Grau's gently ironic sympathy permeates these tales. Though little overt action occurs, the forces that tether people to responsibilities, to rituals and traditions, to family loyalties, and, most tellingly, to life, are gracefully illumined. Franklin Library First Edition Society selection. January 20 (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
CHOICE Review
Grau's first book in eight years, her third collection of stories, is a strong group of tales about women at various crises in their lives. The praise given her first collection, The Black Prince (1955), was deserved, though too hyperbolic; her second, The Wind Shifting West (1973), was a much less consistent effort. Less symbolic than the stories in the first collection and less topical than the second, the stories in Nine Women show the consequences of isolation, of being at the end of a particular stage in life. ``Letting Go,'' for example, shows how a woman is caught up in her parents' patterns of thinking so that she will never know true freedom. ``Ending'' tells of a woman's emotional malaise after her daughter's marriage. ``Widow's Walk'' and ``Summer Shore'' offer contrasting circumstances in older women's lives at the end of summer, both to good effect. ``The Beginning,'' which has some of the fairy-tale elements found in The Black Prince, tells how a black schoolgirl turns into a ``princess'' as she helps model her mother's exotic fashions. ``Home'' is a poignant tale about two lesbians' changing relationship. Though Grau is not technically adventurous nor a deep analyst of character, her power, honesty, and ability to present women, mostly middle-aged, are superb. Grau is in top form in this collection; no longer can she be considered merely one more ``Southern Gothic'' prose stylist. For graduate and undergraduate libraries.-P. Schlueter, Allentown College of St. Francis DeSales
Kirkus Review
As titled, nine stories, each about another woman--some poor but more rich, some black but more white (though some of the black seem white); and each story and each woman poetic in a fleeting way. These are works about disappearance, about ending. In ""Hunter,"" a woman loses her family but miraculously herself survives a terrible air-crash; thereafter she flies constantly--looking for the same crack in time that allowed her to escape death. . .but now wanting in, to be able to join her husband and children. In ""Letting-Go,"" a divorcing young woman stops trying to matter to her monstrously self-absorbed old parents--a particularly fine, bitter story. In ""Home,"" a lesbian couple--two professional women--face the crisis that follows the wish of the younger one to bear a child, to have something of her own that will continue beyond the now; and in ""Housekeeper,"" a widow goes to work for a retired doctor, a man who literally uses himself up in successive hobbies and pursuits. Less successful are the simply scenic stories: ""Ending""--a wealthy black family recovering from a wedding: pure soap opera; and ""Summer Shore""--a rich summer colony's last alcoholic bash of the season. Grau isn't as good a social chronicler as she is a luminist of single lives. Still--on the whole, solid, unflashy, satisfying work by a veteran writer. Copyright ©Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Librarian's View
Syndetics Unbound
Displaying 1 of 1